Let m,q,r,s be integers.
Suppose GCD(r,s) = 1.
Suppose m|qr and m|qs.
Show that m divides q.
This was a result that was assumed in class. I couldn't see the reasoning behind it though.. please provide some guidance/hints.
What I've tried so far:
I note that since (r,s)=1, then either m does not divide r, or m does not divide s.
I suppose that m does not divide r.
Then I note that m|qr but m does not divide r.
I try to come up with a contradiction by assuming that m does not divide q, but since m isn't prime, this doesn't get me far.
Am I going down the wrong path? Is there something I'm failing to consider?
Answer
Hint By basic gcd laws m|qr,qs⇒m|(qr,qs)=q(r,s)=q by (r,s)=1. QED
Or, instead of gcd laws one may use the Bezout identity: jr+ks=1 for some j,k∈Z, hence
m|qr,qs⇒m|j(qr)+k(qs)=q(jr+ks)=q QED
Note how the proof by gcd laws eliminates the variables j,k, which only serve to obfuscate.
Remark It can also be intepreted in terms of orders of elements. Namely, the hypothesis viewed modularly says mod m: r⋅q≡0≡s⋅q, which implies that the additive order of q divides the coprime integers r,s so it must be 1, i.e. 1⋅q≡0, i.e. m|q. This viewpoint is discussed further in some of my posts on order ideals.
No comments:
Post a Comment