I was solving a question from the Regional Math Olympiad (RMO) 2014.
Find all positive real numbers x,y,z such that
2x−2y+1z=12014,2y−2z+1x=12014,2z−2x+1y=12014
Here's my solution:
These expressions are cyclic. Therefore all solution sets must be unordered. This implies that x=y=z.
Thus, x=2014 and the solution is
x=2014y=2014z=2014
Here's the official solution:
Adding the three equations, we get 1x+1y+1z=32014
We can also write them as 2xz−2yz+1=z2014,2xy−2xz+1=x2014,2yz−2xy+1=y2014
Adding these, we get x+y+z=3×2014
Therefore, (1x+1y+1z)(x+y+z)=9
Using AM-GM inequality, we therefore obtain 9=(1x+1y+1z)(x+y+z)≥9×(xyz)13(1xyz)13=9
Hence equality holds and we conclude that x=y=z.
Thus we conclude x=2014y=2014z=2014
What I wonder is if there is something wrong with my approach. If yes, what is it? If no, then why is the official solution so long winded?
Answer
Consider the system of equations
xy+z=1,yz+x=1,zx+y=1
These equations are related by cyclic permutations of (x,y,z), but they are satisified by (1,1,0) (and its cyclic permutations) when x, y and z are not all equal.
There are also solutions where x=y=z=±√5−12, but these are not the only solutions.
No comments:
Post a Comment