Saturday, December 7, 2019

calculus - Doubt on a proof that limxrightarrow0fracsinxx=1



The full proof can be found here. Basically, we compare the three areas that depend on x in the circle of radius 1 shown below.



enter image description here



Regardless of the value of x, we should have




area of sector OAC<area of triangle OAP<area of sector OBP


12x(cosx)2<12(cosx)(sinx)<x2



I have two questions about it:



1) Shouldn't there be a instead of the < sign in the inequality above, since the areas of sector OAC and the area of triangle OAP both become zero when x=π2?



2) If the value of x is such that we end up in the fourth quadrant, the value of sinx becomes negative and the inequality no longer holds (since 12x(cosx)2>0 and 12(cosx)(sinx)<0). How can we go around this?




Thanks in advance.


Answer



1) When we are talking about x0, we are looking at those x close to 0, but not equal to 0. The value of the function at x=0 is just irrelevent. So < is correct.



2) For π2>x>0, we have



12x(cosx)2<12(cosx)(sinx)<x2



This implies that




cosx<sinxx<1cosx



For $\frac{-\pi}{2}y>0$ and hence



cosy<sinyy<1cosy



Note that sinx=sin(y)=siny and cosx=cos(y)=cosy.



So we still have




cosx<sinxx<1cosx


No comments:

Post a Comment

analysis - Injection, making bijection

I have injection f:AB and I want to get bijection. Can I just resting codomain to f(A)? I know that every function i...