Friday, October 25, 2019

radicals - How to prove: if $a,b in mathbb N$, then $a^{1/b}$ is an integer or an irrational number?


It is well known that $\sqrt{2}$ is irrational, and by modifying the proof (replacing 'even' with 'divisible by $3$'), one can prove that $\sqrt{3}$ is irrational, as well. On the other hand, clearly $\sqrt{n^2} = n$ for any positive integer $n$. It seems that any positive integer has a square root that is either an integer or irrational number.



  1. How do we prove that if $a \in \mathbb N$, then $\sqrt a$ is an integer or an irrational number?


I also notice that I can modify the proof that $\sqrt{2}$ is irrational to prove that $\sqrt[3]{2}, \sqrt[4]{2}, \cdots$ are all irrational. This suggests we can extend the previous result to other radicals.



  1. Can we extend 1? That is, can we show that for any $a, b \in \mathbb{N}$, $a^{1/b}$ is either an integer or irrational?


Answer




These (standard) results are discussed in detail in


http://math.uga.edu/~pete/4400irrationals.pdf


This is the second handout for a first course in number theory at the advanced undergraduate level. Three different proofs are discussed:


1) A generalization of the proof of irrationality of $\sqrt{2}$, using the decomposition of any positive integer into a perfect $k$th power times a $k$th power-free integer, followed by Euclid's Lemma. (For some reason, I don't give all the details of this proof. Maybe I should...)


2) A proof using the functions $\operatorname{ord}_p$, very much along the lines of the one Carl Mummert mentions in his answer.


3) A proof by establishing that the ring of integers is integrally closed. This is done directly from unique factorization, but afterwards I mention that it is a special case of the Rational Roots Theorem.


Let me also remark that every proof I have ever seen of this fact uses the Fundamental Theorem of Arithmetic (existence and uniqueness of prime factorizations) in some form. [Edit: I have now seen Robin Chapman's answer to the question, so this is no longer quite true.] However, if you want to prove any particular case of the result, you can use a brute force case-by-case analysis that avoids FTA.


No comments:

Post a Comment

analysis - Injection, making bijection

I have injection $f \colon A \rightarrow B$ and I want to get bijection. Can I just resting codomain to $f(A)$? I know that every function i...