Saturday, June 2, 2018

combinatorics - Combinatorial proof of sumnk=0binom3nk2n=binom3n+1n



I had an exercise to prove the following equation:
nk=0(3nk2n)=(3n+1n)

I was able to prove it using Pascal's Identity a lot of times, but I'm wondering if there is a combinatorial proof of this. Anyone has an idea for a combinatorial proof?


Answer



We can use the method of committee-forming.




Consider a group of 3n+1 people, such that we want to choose a committee of n people from that group. Note nk=0(3nk2n)=nk=0(3nknk)=(3nn)+(3n1n1)+...+(2n0). Select one person. We can either choose for him to not be in the group with (3nn) ways to do so, or be in the group. Assume he is in the group. Next, select a different person. If he is not in the group, we have (3n1n1) ways to choose the committee from the other 3n1 members, and now assume he is in the group, etc.



Alternatively, consider a list of 3n+1 numbers, such that you want to remove 2n+1 of them. Consider the largest number that you remove - if it is 3n+1, there are (3n2n) ways to remove the rest; if it is 3n, there are (3n12n) ways to remove the rest; etc.


No comments:

Post a Comment

analysis - Injection, making bijection

I have injection f:AB and I want to get bijection. Can I just resting codomain to f(A)? I know that every function i...