Let gcd(a,b,c)=1 such that a2,b2,c2 are in arithmetic progression. Show they can be written in the form
a=−p2+2pq+q2
b=p2+q2
c=p2+2pq−q2
for relatively prime integers p,q of different parities.
so if a2,b2,c2 are in arithmetic progression, then a2=x,b2=x+d,c2=x+2d, for x,d∈Z
That means x+x+d=x+d+d⇒2x+d=x+2d⇒x=d.
So then a2=x,b2=2x,c2=3x
Now with primitive pythagorean triples, we have (2pq,p2−q2,p2+q2). I just don't see how to go from here....i'm sure it's easy, but I'm not seeing something.
Answer
Since a2,b2,c2 are in arithmetic progression, a2+c2=2b2. If a is even, then so is c, so 4∣a2+c2=2b2, so b is also even, giving a contradiction.
Thus a is odd. Similarly c is odd, so b is also odd.
(a−b)(a+b)=a2−b2=b2−c2=(b−c)(b+c)
a−b2a+b2=b−c2b+c2
By factoring lemma, there exists integers w,x,y,z such that a−b2=wx,a+b2=yz,b−c2=wy,b+c2=xz. Now
a=wx+yz,b=yz−wx=wy+xz,c=xz−wy
y(z−w)=x(z+w). Again by factoring lemma, there exists integers d,e,f,g such that y=de,z−w=fg,x=df,z+w=eg. Now
z=eg+fg2=ge+f2,w=eg−fg2=ge−f2 a=wx+yz=dfge−f2+dege+f2=dg2(e2+2ef−f2) b=wy+xz=dege−f2+dfge+f2=dg2(e2+f2) c=xz−wy=dfge+f2−dege−f2=dg2(−e2+2ef+f2)
If dg is divisible by 4 or an odd prime p, then a,b,c will not be relatively prime. Thus dg=±1 or ±2.
If dg=±2, then a=±(e2+2ef−f2),b=±(e2+f2),c=±(−e2+2ef+f2). Clearly gcd, so e, f are relatively prime. If e, f have the same parity, then a, b, c are all even, a contradiction, so e, f have different parities.
If dg= \pm 1, then a=\pm \frac{e^2+2ef-f^2}{2}, b=\pm \frac{e^2+f^2}{2}, c=\pm \frac{-e^2+2ef+f^2}{2}. Thus e, f must have the same parity. Put e+f=2p, e-f=2q, then e=p+q, f=p-q, and
a=\pm \frac{e^2+2ef-f^2}{2}=\pm \frac{(p+q)^2+2(p+q)(p-q)-(p-q)^2}{2}=\pm (p^2+2pq-q^2) b=\pm \frac{e^2+f^2}{2}=\pm \frac{(p+q)^2+(p-q)^2}{2}=\pm (p^2+q^2) c=\pm \frac{-e^2+2ef+f^2}{2}=\pm \frac{-(p+q)^2+2(p+q)(p-q)+(p-q)^2}{2}=\mp(-p^2+2pq+q^2)
Again, p, q must be relatively prime and be of different parities.
Finally, combining the 2 cases, a, b, c can be written as
a=\epsilon_a (p^2+2pq-q^2), b=\epsilon_b (p^2+q^2), c=\epsilon_c (-p^2+2pq+q^2)
where each \epsilon_a, \epsilon_b, \epsilon_c are 1 or -1.
No comments:
Post a Comment