Can we construct a monotonic function f:R→R such that there is a dense set in some interval (a,b) for which f is discontinuous at all points in the dense set? What about a strictly monotonic function?
My intuition tells me that such a function is impossible.
Here is a rough sketch of an attempt at proving that such a function does not exist: we could suppose a function satisfies these conditions. Take an ϵ>0 and two points x,y in this dense set such that $x
However, after this point, I am stuck. Could we somehow partition (x,y) into n subintervals and conclude that there must be some point on the dense set that is continuous?
Answer
Such a function is possible.
Let Q={qn:n∈N} be an enumeration of the rational numbers, and define
f:R→R:x↦∑qn≤x12n.
The series ∑n≥012n is absolutely convergent, so (1) makes sense. If $x
$$\lim_{x\to {q_n}^-}f(x)=\sum_{q_k
Thus, f is discontinuous on a set that is dense in R (and in every open interval of R).
No comments:
Post a Comment