I want to show that n2∣P(n), where P(n)=n2(n+1)2(n+2)(n+3)48 for every odd positive integer n. The approach I took involved showing that P(n)n2 is always an integer (for such n), but then I had to create a polynomial even more complex and then prove nine different cases. While it did provide a valid proof (as far as I know), I have a feeling it was more work than I needed.
So my question is: are there "simpler" proofs to this problem, and what are their approaches/methods? By simpler I roughly mean: prove less cases, reduce the problem to a simpler form, etc; basically a solution that takes up less "space" on paper. (I know that's not the best explanation, sorry!)
Thank you very much!
Answer
I'm not sure what you did, but showing that P(n)n2=(n+1)2(n+2)(n+3)48 is always an integer if n is odd is quite straightforward. You just have to show that (n+1)2(n+2)(n+3) is always divisible by 48=24⋅3. It's always divisible by 3 since one of n+1,n+2, and n+3 is a multiple of 3.
The factors of 2 are a little more complicated but not bad. Since n is odd, n+1 and n+3 are even, so (n+1)2(n+3) gives at least 3 factors of 2. Moreover, one of n+1 and n+3 is a multiple of 4, which gives one extra factor of 2. So in total there are at least 4 factors of 2.
The moral here is that when thinking about divisibility questions, factor. We keep the numerator of P(n)n2 in its factored form, so we can identify the contributions from each individual factor. And to test divisibility by 48, we split it into its prime factorization so we can look for each prime factor separately.
No comments:
Post a Comment