Sunday, July 22, 2018

calculus - How find limit displaystylelimntoinftynleft(1tfraclnnnright)n





How find this limit limnn(1lnnn)n



Answer



Let f(n)=n(1lognn)n and we need to calculate the limit of f(n) as n through integer values. The best approach would be to analyze the behavior of logf(n). Clearly we have logf(n)=logn+nlog(1lognn) and if n>1 we know that 0<lognn<1 We also know that the following inequality x<log(1x)<x1x holds for 0<x<1. Replacing x with (logn)/n in the above inequality we get lognlognn<log(1lognn)<lognn Multiplying by n we get nlognlognn<nlog(1lognn)<logn Using (2) we now have (logn)2lognn<logf(n)<0 Now we can see that
A=limn(logn)2lognn=limn(logn)2n(lognn1)=limn(logn)2n1lognn1=0101=0



In the above derivation we have used the standard result that limn(logn)anb=0 for any positive numbers a,b. Using Squeeze theorem in equation (6) and noting the equation (7) we get that logf(n)0 as n. Hence f(n)1 as n. The desired limit is therefore equal to 1.



Update: Some other answers make use of the symbol , but it is wrong unless provided with further justification. The definition of the symbol in the current context is like this. If limna(n)b(n)=1 then we write a(n)b(n). And because of this definition we can replace a(n) by b(n) while calculating limits where a(n) is used in the multiplicative context. To be more specific if we have a(n)b(n) then while calculating the limit of an expression like a(n)c(n) we can replace a(n) by b(n) and just calculate the limit of b(n)c(n) to get final answer. This is justified because we can write limna(n)c(n)=limna(n)b(n)b(n)c(n)=limn1b(n)c(n) Replacement of a(n) by b(n) in other contexts must be justified by further analysis and it may generate wrong answer also.



Further Update: In case you have access to powerful technique of series expansions then the limit can be calculated easily as follows:
logf(n)=logn+nlog(1lognn)=lognn{lognn+(logn)22n2+o((logn)2n2)}=(logn)22n+o((logn)2n)
Using the fact that (logn)2/n0 as n we can see that logf(n)0 and hence f(n)1 as n. My preferred approach is to use simpler tools (theorems on algebra of limits, Squeeze theorem etc), but advanced tools like series expansions and L'Hospital give the answer very easily.


No comments:

Post a Comment

analysis - Injection, making bijection

I have injection f:AB and I want to get bijection. Can I just resting codomain to f(A)? I know that every function i...